Marissa, a resident of a small town in Kentucky, learned that for some time her drinking water may have been contaminated with so-called “forever chemicals” or PFAS. It’s really a collection of chemicals used in products like fire-suppression foam, cookware, stain-resistant sprays, and food packaging. A local public radio reporter covering the story asked Marissa for her reaction. “I was never informed,” she said. “And now I’m worried, like, I hope I don’t have issues someday in my life.”

Marissa’s concern is like that of many people who find themselves in this situation and is at the center of this episode. When a case like Marissa’s goes to court, plaintiffs will seek a ruling that the responsible parties pay for years of medical monitoring. That means they often sue without signs of an existing injury, and defendants must pay for something when an injury may not have arisen.

Attorney, author, and court-appointed case neutral, Edgar C. Gentle III, says that the approach is antiquated. He outlines a better approach in his 2014 essay, titled “The Medical Monitoring Tort Remedy: Its Nationwide Status, Rationale, and Practical Application (A Possible Dynamic Tort Remedy for Long-Term Tort Maladies). Now he shares his latest insights on the Emerging Litigation Podcast.

Ed Gentle is the Founding Partner of Gentle Turner & Benson, LLC in Birmingham, Ala. He is a Rhodes Scholar and has five college degrees, three in law. He has practiced for nearly four decades, spending 90% of his professional time serving as a neutral assigned by judges to oversee aspects of mass tort litigation and settlements. He has helped create and administer over $2 billion in settlements during the past 25 years. Education: Bachelor of Science, Auburn University, summa cum laude, Danforth Scholar; Master of Science, University of Miami, summa cum laudeMaytag Fellow; B.A. and M.A. Degrees, Oxford University, Rhodes Scholar, Honors in Jurisprudence; and Juris Doctorate, University of Alabama School of Law, Hugo Black Scholar.

Thanks for listening!

If you like what you hear, please give us a rating. You’d be amazed at how much that helps.

If you have questions for Tom or would like to participate, you can reach him at Editor@LitigationConferences.com.

Ask him about creating this kind of content for your firm — podcasts, webinars, blogs, articles, papers, and more.

Tom Hagy
Litigation Enthusiast and
Host of the Emerging Litigation Podcast
LinkedIn

Our Guest

Ed Gentle
Ed GentleGentle Turner & Benson LLC

Your Host

Tom Hagy
Tom HagyEditor-in-Chief
Tom Hagy is host and producer of the Emerging Litigation Podcast, now approaching its 120th episode with more than 15,000 downloads, along with thousands of additional views on the HB Litigation News YouTube channel. He edits a litigation blog that ranked as the most read in its category on JD Supra in 2025 and regularly writes about emerging legal issues for the HB website.
Join Tom on the Podcast

Share This - Choose Your Platform!